The Best Eye Makeup (2021 Reviews)

Vanessa Manning
Written by
Last update:

If you’re like most women, you love the idea of having a morning routine that takes just a few minutes.

One important part of this is getting your makeup just right. It’s one thing to have flawless skin, but another to know how to apply makeup that enhances your beautiful features without cluttering your face or looking too heavy.

In this article, we look at the top rated eye makeups available, including my personal favorites. Whether you’re looking for something inexpensive or something more expensive, these road bike helmets will please you.

NameCategoryProduct
CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye ShadowBest OverallCoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye Shadow
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure PigmentsBudget PickMaybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure Pigments
SHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose PowderUpgrade PickSHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose Powder

1. CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye Shadow

Our rating: 9 / 10

CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Delicious smell
  • Very easy to blend and diffuse
  • Matte and shimmery textures available
  • Highly pigmented

If you are looking for something bold, beautiful, affordable and versatile for your daily makeup routine, then you should consider this palette as it’s my top choice.

The colors are buttery soft and highly pigmented, making it easy to blend the shadows in with other colors and build up the intensity depending on your needs. Copper Fling 24/7 Glide-On eye shadow palette has a very sweet scent to it that reminds me of a promising future filled with passionate lovemaking.

2. Highly Pigmented Eyeshadow Palette,YMH BEAUTE 9 Color Bright Eye Shadow Palettes Matte Shimmer Eyeshadow 80's Makeup Palette Long Lasting Blendable Colorful Make Up Pallet

Our rating: 9 / 10

Highly Pigmented Eyeshadow Palette,YMH BEAUTE 9 Color Bright Eye Shadow Palettes Matte Shimmer Eyeshadow 80's Makeup Palette Long Lasting Blendable Colorful Make Up Pallet

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great Product
  • Colors are pigmented

This great product is a compact shadow palette that will be very convenient along with the brushes, because you can take it everywhere you go.

The shadow can last longer because of its great pigmentation.

This product included a wide-angle brush and a small precise brush. If you want to choose another eyeshadow, a brush is optional.

3. Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup

Our rating: 9 / 10

Best Pro Eyeshadow Palette Makeup

Check Price on Amazon

4. Eye Primer Makeup Eyeshadow Base: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Base to Prevent Oily Lids and Creasing

Our rating: 9 / 10

Eye Primer Makeup Eyeshadow Base: Elizabeth Mott Thank Me Later Eye Shadow Base to Prevent Oily Lids and Creasing

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Waterproof formula guarantees your eye makeup will not fade or smudge throughout the day.
  • Glides on smoothly and dries quickly creating a barrier between your skin and the eye shadow preventing from getting creases and smudging.
  • Very easy to apply with just a swipe of this lightweight silicone water based product.
  • Prevents eye shadow color from fading on lids all day.

Cons:

  • Too little of this eye shadow primer is just not enough to cover the whole lid.
  • Parabens are a controversial preservative some people can have an allergic reaction to.

/0.35oz

This eye shadow base is transparent when applied on the lids leaving you with a nice base for your eye shadow. For the price, this is a really good quality, lightweight, long lasting eye cream.

5. Honeybee Gardens Angelic Powder Colors Stackable Mineral

Our rating: 8 / 10

Honeybee Gardens Angelic Powder Colors Stackable Mineral

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Good for sensitive eyes
  • Long lasting if you use a primer
  • Affordable
  • Talc Free

Clear Top & Turquoise Bottom Top (1 Pack).

Something magical happens when you mix baking soda (you know, the stuff in your oven’s cleaner) and cornstarch. It’s called kaolin. (You won’t find that name on any of its beauty products though because that would cause some confusion.) In case you’re curious, kaolin and feldspar are the ones responsible for giving your 1950s lovin’ kitchen countertop its smooth appearance.

This is pretty darn cool for me since I love the fact that I’m continuing to use the same ingredients to make my beauty products that I use in my kitchen.

6. UCANBE Professional 18 Pigmented Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

Our rating: 8 / 10

UCANBE Professional 18 Pigmented Eyeshadow Makeup Palette

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Very high-quality
  • Bold, long-lasting colors
  • Huge savings
  • Great for professional use

If you’re someone who uses a lot of eyeshadows in various colors from a very wide range of brands, this product is the best cruelty-free cosmetic palette you can buy for your money.

You will have 18 different highly pigmented shades, from matte to metallic, all in one palette. Due to this large amount of colors, you will be able to create any type of makeup you want for any occasion.

They are very smooth, glide on the eyelid smoothly and crease-free. You can apply several layers of the same shade without clumping. Makeup will last all day long.

7. Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow

Our rating: 8 / 10

Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Long-lasting color that doesn’t crease or fade
  • Only a small amount is needed to provide great color payoff
  • Large sized shadow is easy to apply, and the applicator on the long wear crayon is phenomenal
  • Applicator tip covers every inch of your eyelid
  • Lightweight and creamy

For eye shadow, I recommend Revlon Colorstay Creme Eye Shadow, Longwear Blendable Matte or Shimmer Eye Makeup with Applicator Brush in Purple, Black Currant (740). The colors are long lasting and can be blended well together.That said, some of them do get a little intense for daily wear.

They are waterproof, and I don’t know anyone that goes running with only waterproof eye shadow and clothing. They can also be used as a base for other eye shadows. Ultimately, they can be used for your day and night wear. Even when you are putting them on, you can’t feel the makeup. It is very lightweight and creamy.

8. stila Shimmer And Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Our rating: 8 / 10

stila Shimmer And Glow Liquid Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Beautiful shimmery finish
  • Many products to choose from

Once you try this eye shadow you won’t be able to ignore it. The metallic, shimmery finish will have you mesmerized.

The colors are so popping and gorgeous you definitely need this one for your collection.

You don’t really need to have any eye shadows if you have this one.

9. Mally Beauty

Our rating: 8 / 10

Mally Beauty

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • One of the highest rated drugstore eye shadow sticks on the market
  • Pretty easy to apply
  • Easy to use all over your eyelid
  • Can be applied with a blending brush to make it easier for you to apply
  • Can be combine with Mally’s eyelid primer for the boldest look possible
  • Lasts all day without fading

What makes Mally’s shadow sticks so special is the fact that they are extremely long lasting. Many make-up lovers love this product because they get to wear their makeup for a very long time without it fading or smearing. This eyeliner is the best selling eye shadow stick in the United States for a reason. This post is a review of these wonderful eyeliners.

10. Cargo Swimmable Longwear Eye Shadow Stick

Our rating: 8 / 10

Cargo Swimmable Longwear Eye Shadow Stick

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • It offers a tremendous amount of variety for a reasonable price.
  • It is light, so there is not too much pressure on the lids
  • They do last about 15 hours and they are waterproof, so you can rest easy knowing there is no risk of smudging or bleeding

Cons:

  • Too many options may be overwhelming for those who are just starting out with eye makeup
  • Some users found that the colors are not very long lasting

The Cargo Swimmable Longwear Eye Shadow Stick comes in five vibrant colors – Fiery Coral, Midnight Mauve, Pink Peach, Purple Mangosteen, and Sweet Green Tea. All the colors are great but there are two colors that stand out – Sugar Plum and Fiery Coral.

Sugar Plum is a vibrant and rich purple that is perfect for those who love wearing purple on their eyes. It can really make your eyes look more vibrant and lively and it is perfect for going to those special occasions.

For those with a more traditional taste and for those who are not ready to wear such a bold color, Fiery Coral is perfect for those who want the benefits of a bold color with a less bold color. It is a beautiful orange that is perfect for those who want to wear an eye shadow that is bold yet attractive.

11. Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow

Our rating: 8 / 10

Almay Velvet Foil Cream Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Creamy texture spreads easily
  • Comes in a wider variety of colors than traditional metallic eye shadows
  • Stays on during exercise
  • Smudge proof packaging

Cons:

  • Can be quite shiny
  • More expensive than traditional metallic eye shadows

The Almay Velvet Foil Metallic Eye Shadows come in a variety of metallic colors, are smooth to the touch, and can be used as a base for adding a metallic color or as an accent for other eye shadow looks.

This Stila version is similar to its 90’s predecessor, which had such a strong following that fans would line up around the block just to get their hands on the product.

All you have to do is apply it straight from the tube to your eyelids and watch as the color appears to magically grow in size.

12. Jolie Waterproof Indelible Creme Eye Shadow 3g

Our rating: 8 / 10

Jolie Waterproof Indelible Creme Eye Shadow 3g

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Permanent eye shadow
  • Semi-permanent
  • Long-lasting
  • Skin-friendly
  • Natural & safe ingredients
  • Waterproof
  • Suitable for sensitive skin
  • No irritation
  • No allergy
  • Lightweight

Cons:

  • Not suitable to apply on scar
  • Not long-lasting enough
  • Tend to crumble up if not applied well
  • If you're not a serious and meticulous liner expert, be prepared that you might mess up the item or other users.
  • Smell has a bit of a mild acidic smell that is peculiar, otherwise it doesn't have any significant scent at all.

Best Eyeshadow Reviews:

If you have a minimalist eyeshadow palette bag, I'm sure that this item will complement with your entire existing collection. It's light, easy to blend and extremely easy to apply. So, it's definitely the best eyeliner for beginners out there. It's has a wonderful colour payoff but as a con, it is not long-lasting, at least not for our purposes. You can easily retouch your eyeliner, but it would be best to avoid retouching due to product wastage. Nevertheless, the staying power is still good when compared to the others that in the market.

13. EyeShadow Palette

Our rating: 7 / 10

EyeShadow Palette

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Loving the color selection
  • I love the bottles and colours
  • good packaging. Good for gift
  • Super pigmented. Opaque and vibrant.
  • Best quality palettes.
  • A+ products for me
  • Great pigmentation, long lasting.
  • High quality eyeshadow
  • Soft quality brush included
  • Great possible x-mas gift

Cons:

  • Wish the palette holders were a bit more sturdy
  • Good but nothing special
  • Somewhat powdery
  • Nothing stand out
  • easily crease

14. jane iredale Eye Shere Liquid Eye Shadow

Our rating: 7 / 10

jane iredale Eye Shere Liquid Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Lightweight
  • Long lasting
  • Sensitive skin friendly
  • 12 vibrant shades
  • Smooth and creamy
  • Can be used as eyeliner and brow highlighter
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Available in two sizes (silver lid, gold lid)

Cons:

  • Expensive
  • Easy to spread
  • Not water resistant
  • Packaging is not very sturdy

This bi-phase liquid eye shadow is so silky that you’ll forget you’re even wearing any makeup. I’ve been using the jane iredale Eye Shere for years now, and I’m never disappointed because it is one of the rare makeup products that lives up to its claims. Here’s why I’ll always carry one in my bag.

First, it’s light weight, creamy, and waterproof. This package comes with a handy applicator that features a pointed side for eyeliner, a rounded side for shading, and a flat side for applying highlighter. Applying this eye shadow is a piece of cake because it’s so lightweight. And the silver lid packaging can flip to become a mirror for quick makeup touchups.

15. Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure Pigments

Our rating: 7 / 10

Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure Pigments

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to blend
  • Natural-looking
  • Last all day
  • Budget-friendly
  • Doesn’t dry up very easily

Cons:

  • Not waterproof
  • Not very pigmented

The budget-friendly Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure Pigments are great if you like subtle, natural makeup looks.

They are very blendable and natural-looking, so if you like to experiment with bold colors or if you’re a beginner looking to adapt to wearing makeup, these eye shadows could be the perfect fit for you.

They stay on for hours even if you don’t use a primer, and they don’t dry up like the more popular ones. You can get up to 12 hours of wear out of them, according to reviews.

16. Beauty For Real Shadow STX 24-7 Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick

Our rating: 7 / 10

Beauty For Real Shadow STX 24-7 Waterproof Eyeshadow Stick

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Eye Shadow Applicator Glides on Smoothly and Sets in Seconds
  • Creamy, Non-Creamy, and Powdery All-Day Long Wear
  • Available in Different Shades

We Recommend this eyeshadow all day long as it is the main criteria to judge whether eye shadow is good. It is too heavy for a lightweight and a little light for a heavy one.

In short, it is a perfect eye shadow for daily use. You can apply this shadow on eyelid and brow bone with a little bit moisture of the primer. If you want your makeup to last all day long, this is the best eye makeup product for you.

Shades available: we have 14 shades available. Different shades offers you different options. You can find your perfect one with ease.

17. RMS Eye Polish

Our rating: 7 / 10

RMS Eye Polish

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • RMS offers some great colors you can’t find anywhere else
  • A luxury item

Eye Shadow Boards, Mellow Cosmetics (a very close second).

18. SHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose Powder

Our rating: 7 / 10

SHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose Powder

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Very affordable price
  • Compact to travel with
  • Great little palette
  • Can be used wet or dry

19. Peripera Sugar Twinkle Liquid Eye Shadow

Our rating: 7 / 10

Peripera Sugar Twinkle Liquid Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • It’s not tested on animals
  • Very pigmented
  • Doesn’t clog pores
  • Glide on easily
  • Cute packaging
  • Can be worn alone or with other eye makeup
  • Comes in a ton of colors
  • Affordable price
  • Easy to find
  • Very long-wearing

The Peripera Sugar Twinkle Liquid Eye Shadow is hands down the best eye shadow you can buy in terms of quality and value.

It’s long-lasting, affordable, and easily accessible. You can find it pretty much anywhere.

They offer an incredible range of beautiful colors, and the pigmentation is mind-blowing. In addition, this is one of the cheapest eye shadows you can buy that still gives you incredible quality.

20. TIGI Longwearing Creme Eye Shadow

Our rating: 5 / 10

TIGI Longwearing Creme Eye Shadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Wears well
  • Easy to apply
  • Good color selection

If you’re after a wet/dry eye shadow look on a budget then this one by TIGI is a good choice, though it’s based off a powder formula. It’s affordable and you can create intense, long-lasting looks with it as they don’t easily fade.

The eye shadow comes in a retractable pot with a sponge applicator. It’s easy to apply and is suitable for just about any occasion. It has a long lasting effect and it blends well with other products, so you can do as little or as much as you want with it.

Some brands boast that this eye shadow is sweat and water proof, but there hasn’t been much evidence showing that to be the case, so use with caution. It’s also important to follow the directions on the package and remove the shadow when you’re done with it so there is less chance of your lids getting irritated.

21. trèStiQue Color & Smudge Shadow Crayon

Our rating: 5 / 10

trèStiQue Color & Smudge Shadow Crayon

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to create the perfect smoky eye
  • Long wearing
  • Ultimate multi-tasking tool, 2 in 1 pencil allows you to apply color and smudge with the click of a button
  • Rich color pigment
  • Smudgeable without irritating the eye
  • Crease resistant

Cons:

  • 2 products in 1; some reviews indicate this makes it too bulky
  • Not built for long wear

22. Maybelline New York Color Tattoo Eye Chrome Eyeshadow

Our rating: 5 / 10

Maybelline New York Color Tattoo Eye Chrome Eyeshadow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Priced well
  • Great pigmentation
  • No creasing
  • No fall-out
  • Packed with color-payoff
  • Sleek packaging
  • Doesn’t smear
  • Easy to blend
  • Water-resistant
  • Long-lasting

Every time I wear a Maybelline Color Tattoo Eye Shadow, I get compliments on my makeup. I’m not kidding. This product is that good.

The colors glide on smoothly and last all day. There’s little to no fall-out from these shadows, which is rare in the drugstore world. Use them as liners, bases, highlighters, or for that matter, your entire eye look.

I know lots of people who’ve found their perfect match in this collection. If you’re looking for a one-color eyeshadow palette for any reason, definitely pick this one up.

23. Mineral Glitter Eyeshadow Makeup Powder

Our rating: 4 / 10

Mineral Glitter Eyeshadow Makeup Powder

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Gives you a whopping 5 grams worth of makeup for the price you pay
  • Goes on creamy
  • Contains plenty of glitter, but it doesn’t feel rough against your eyes
  • Doesn’t fall off of your eyes (although it’s hard to apply)
  • Easily blends with other eyeshadow colors
  • Beautiful colors
  • Adds color to your eyeshadow without adding a ton of extra product
  • Opaque product
  • Long lasting

Cons:

  • Very hard to apply if you don’t use a blending sponge or brush with it
  • Not super pigmented if you don’t use a base
  • Not the most affordable option on the market
  • Doesn’t come with all of the colors that it says (for instance, mine came with 5, but it said 6 ) and the colors didn’t match the color wheel they showed. ( I ended up getting 3 black shades, instead of 1 gold, 2 black, 1 white, 1 silver, and 1 multi-color ).

This is an absolutely beautiful eyeshadow. It is pigmented enough to give you a color payoff if you build it up, but I feel like it's a tad too pigmented.

24. Glitter Liquid Eyeshadow Highly Pigmented Glow

Our rating: 3 / 10

Glitter Liquid Eyeshadow Highly Pigmented Glow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • 3 layer formula
  • 18 hours long-lasting

Cons:

  • little pricey
  • strong taste

Kei brand several products such as nails, lipsticks, eyeliner, makeup base, eye shadows, loose powder, BB cream, and so on. They’re famous for their super high quality products.

According to most users, these eyeshadows are both long-lasting and highly pigmented. It’s easy to apply and blend. Many users are satisfied with the beautiful color when apply on their skin. Some of them even say that it looks better than the more expensive brands. The only complaint is the strong sweet scent and taste.

Other brands that you can try are:

  • little pricey
  • strong taste

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Which is the best brand for eye makeup?

When you are looking for eye makeup, the task can be a bit frustrating because there are just too many brands and too many colors to choose from. In addition, you have to choose from different varieties and formulations, such as gel, fluid, powder, cream and so on. To make a quick shopping trip more easily, you should know some basic information about eye makeup. Here comes a list of some of the best eye makeups:

Which is the best eye shadow?

Eye shadow is used to create the desired eye look for the makeup. There are a variety of different eye makeup looks one can create using various colors of eye makeup and shades.

The cosmetics are:

  • Eye Shadow
  • Eye liner
  • Eye shadow primer
  • Eye shadow Primer
  • Foundation
  • Brow pencil
  • Eyeliner
  • Mascara
  • Eye shadow

Using eye shadow is very easy. There are various types of eye shadow available in the market.

What is the best long lasting eyeshadow?

Among the best long lasting and crease free eyeshadows on the market are the 24-Hour Shadow Sticks by e.l.f. Cosmetics. This long lasting eyeshadow comes in a convenient, compact tube that is also very affordable. Many people who have used the product have reported no creasing whatsoever, which is saying something since they are water-based. Just pop it in your pocketbook, purse, backpack, or even gym bag when you're working out so it's available as a quick touch-up during the day. Besides, they are also very easy to apply and last all day. The waterproof formula will not smudge even when exercising or sweating. These eye shadows are ideal for hot and humid weather because they have a light texture and are completely smudge proof. Since they are from e.l.f. they are very affordable and very good quality. It's a very good deal.

Which lorac palette is the best?

I can say that this single palette is one of the best ones that I have ever bought from the drugstore. I like the colors, and the quality is great. It stays on all day even with my oily skin. I would recommend this to anyone.

I’m an avid fan of Lorac and this palette is truly one of the best ones that I have ever tried. The colors are extremely pigmented, and it blends very well to create a very natural look.

The shades are nice. The neutral matte colors are great to create a very natural look but the included side has glitter shades that are fun to play with.

The eyeshadows are creamy and the colors pigmented. They are highly blendable and long lasting. The color payoff is amazing.

Conclusion

How much of a difference can a little color around the eyes make? Well, it can make a face bright and noticeable from a distance or mood bright and clear from just a few feet away. No matter what kind of eye makeup you apply or what you choose to wear, it’s important to ensure the eye makeup you wear is suitable for your skin type. Before you make that purchase consider the following best eye makeup reviews. Got it from a friend? We double-checked this recommendation before making it.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
CoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye ShadowBest OverallCoverGirl Bombshell Shine Shadow Eye Shadow
Maybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure PigmentsBudget PickMaybelline New York Eye Studio Color Tattoo Pure Pigments
SHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose PowderUpgrade PickSHANY Eye Sparkle/Eye shadow Loose Powder